🚨I’ll be live at 10 a.m. ET with Graham🚨
We’ll talk markets and the bull and bear cases, SpaceX spending the $85 billion it raised, Amazon’s bid to sell custom AI chips, this week’s biggest earnings and more [tap to join us for Opening Playbook]
Here’s something that happens to me all the time.
I’ll show someone the math behind two different approaches to trading. One makes more money over time. The other wins more often.
And without fail, I get the same question: “Yeah, but which one’s the higher win rate?”
It’s a weird response when you think about it. I just told you which one makes more money. But somehow that’s not the answer traders want to hear.
I’ll even lay out the numbers and explain that, based on the way I’ve tested it — not every possible way, but consistently enough — if you have a mechanical advantage, it’s more profitable to simply let it go. Let the edge play out. Let the system work.
Yet the reply I often get is the same refrain: “Yeah, well, this one makes more money… but which one’s the higher win rate?”
There’s something psychologically comforting about being right more often, even if it means making less money.
But if you’ve got a mechanical edge — a real, statistically proven advantage — the math is pretty clear. It’s more profitable to take your full wins when you get them and take your full losses when they come.
Now, here’s the catch. That approach can be rough. Your positions can be in winning territory one day and turn into full losses the next. That’s especially true with Two-Way Options trades, where you can be up big one day and staring at a full loss the next.
And that emotional whipsaw is tough to stomach, which is why so many traders gravitate toward the other option.
The Trade-Off Between Profit and Psychology
If you want a smoother equity curve and a higher win rate, you can put a target on it. When you get a big move, you take your money and run.
You’re banking wins early. You’re cutting off the downside of reversals. You’re training your brain to associate your system with winning.
But you’re also leaving money on the table.
Because when you have a mechanical advantage, the math works better when you let your full edge unfold. That approach produces more net profit — even if you’re wrong more often along the way.
So which one should you choose?
I’m not here to tell you there’s only one right answer. I’m here to give you transparency so you can choose based on your personality rather than just the mathematical edge.
If you want maximum profit and you can handle the swings, stick to the mechanical system. Let it run. Take the hits when they come. Trust the edge.
If you want psychological comfort and you’d rather see green more often, take early profits when you get them. Just know you’re trading edge for consistency.
What This Looks Like in Practice
Let’s say you’re in a Two-Way Opyions trade. It moves in your favor on Thursday. You’re up big.
But Friday is expiration. What happens if it sells off Thursday and then gaps higher Friday? That happens all the time.
You could take the profit Thursday and walk away clean. That’s the high-win-rate move.
Or you could let it ride into Friday and trust that your setup has an edge over time. That’s the higher-profit move.
Neither one is wrong. But they’re different games.
The key is knowing which game you’re playing — and why. Most traders never make that choice consciously. They react. They take profits when they’re scared and let losses run when they’re hoping.
But when you understand the trade-off, you can be intentional. You can decide whether you’re optimizing for profit or consistency and then build your system accordingly.
Just don’t fool yourself into thinking you can have both.
Now don’t forget to join us at 10 a.m. ET weekdays for Opening Playbook, and at 3:30 p.m. ET Closing Playbook!
Nate Tucci
Tucci Trades
You can also follow along and join the conversation for real-time analysis, trade ideas, market insights and more in my official Telegram channel!
Important Note: No one from the New Money Crew team or Tucci Trades will ever contact you directly on Telegram.
*This is for informational and educational purposes only. There is inherent risk in trading, so trade at your own risk.Â
