Why 2% Moves Are the New 5% Crashes and How I’m Trading It

🚨 I’ll be live at 10 a.m. ET with Graham Lindman🚨
Special guests hosts JD and Silas are on deck today and they’ll have some special guests of their own. They’ll also crown the first ever Fireside Trader tournament winner and more [tap to join us for Opening Playbook]

 

The president made an extremely dramatic announcement on Tuesday, and the market barely flinched. We were down about 0.8%, which in another era would’ve been unthinkable given the tone of the headline.

Here’s what matters: We stayed inside the market maker move the entire time. The expected volatility range already accounted for that kind of reaction, even with news that should have triggered something much larger.

Events like this used to drive 5% moves. Now we’re seeing a fraction of that, and the market almost seems to pause and ask if the news is actually actionable before committing to direction. That hesitation is changing how shocks translate into price.

Then Wednesday proved the point from the other side. We saw a 2.5% gap up on news of a ceasefire, and yet, the market still refused to spiral into a runaway rally. It found its level, respected the range, and stayed in the box.

The Pattern I’m Watching

In our Opening Playbook members meeting on Tuesday, I laid out the expectation: We’d likely push lower near the open, test key levels, then settle somewhere in between. In other words, a gap, some range expansion, but ultimately neutral conditions.

That’s exactly how it played out. We got the initial move, but no real follow-through outside the expected range.

Zooming out, the pattern is even clearer. Over the last 20 sessions, only a handful have closed outside the market maker move, even though most have tested those extremes intraday.

That tells us the market is still reacting emotionally, but it’s reverting instead of extending. We’re hitting volatility extremes, but we’re not sustaining them.

The market is pricing in chaos — it’s just not spiraling with it.

How This Shapes My Trades

This is exactly why I’m leaning into more defensive, structured setups right now. When the market hesitates instead of cascading, smaller cushions with higher efficiency start to make more sense.

For example, I put on a trade with about a 2% cushion on S&P 500 (SPY) for an overnight move. It’s a tighter buffer than usual, but in this environment, the probability of staying inside that range is higher.

Someone messaged me saying, Nate, you put on that iron condor expecting neutral action, and we were down 0.8%. That’s fair, but staying inside the expected move is still a win.

The most likely outcome, even intraday, is some degree of mean reversion. That doesn’t eliminate the chance of a 2% move in either direction, but it does shift the probabilities back toward balance.

And that’s what I’m leaning on: The market is getting better at absorbing extreme headlines without breaking down. If that continues, defensive, high-efficiency trades may offer the best risk-reward on the board right now.

Now don’t forget to join us at 10 a.m. ET weekdays for Opening Playbook, and at 3:30 p.m. ET Closing Playbook!

Nate Tucci
Tucci Trades

Follow along and join the conversation for real-time analysis, trade ideas, market insights and more!

• Telegram: https://t.me/nate_tucci
• YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@NewMoneyCrew

Important Note: No one from the New Money Crew team or Tucci Trades will ever contact you directly on Telegram.

*This is for informational and educational purposes only. There is inherent risk in trading, so trade at your own risk.

P.S. Want Free Access To My Top Income Secret?

You’ll see how to target $250, $500 and even $1,000 on a $2,500 stake every single week from the market, without trying to predict the direction.

Get Free Access Here

Disclaimer: We develop tools and strategies to the best of our ability, but no one can guarantee the future. There is always a risk of loss when trading. Past performance is not indicative of future results. While we have used the Income Machine with great success, we cannot guarantee future results. What you will see today are some of the best examples over the last few months. There were bigger winners, smaller winners, and losers. Since the Income Machine is a tool for traders and not a trading service, profits and performance will vary among users.