My Low VIX Strategy: Trading Time for ROI in Defensive Options Positions

by | Jan 14, 2026

>>> Be sure to join me and Kane Shieh weekdays at 3:30 PM ET for Closing Playbook — we’ll do some live trading, teach you our methods, cover what’s moving markets and more, click HERE to JOIN Live! <<<

 

Ever feel like the market’s stuck in low gear and your usual setups just aren’t giving you the edge they used to?

That’s exactly what happens when the Cboe Volatility Index (VIX) drops to 14. Everything compresses. Your cushion shrinks. And suddenly, you’re forced to make a choice:

Do you trade time for ROI — or ROI for cushion?

Let me show you what I mean — and how I’ve been thinking about this in real trades.

The Expected Move Tells the Story

When you look at something like Mini S&P 500 index options (XSP) for example, say the expected move on 1DTE (one day till expiration) is about $3.90 — that’s less than 1%.

And as you give the market more time, it naturally has to account for a larger potential move.

So, say that same expected move that sits at $3.90 on 1DTE jumps to around $5.47 on 2DTE and continues growing as you go further out.

It’s a clear reminder that time expands the range of outcomes the market must price in.

When volatility is stubbornly low, one of the simplest adjustments you can make is to add a little time.

You’re effectively expanding the range of where winning opportunities can happen.

The ROI Trade-Off

Now, adding time doesn’t come for free. There’s a trade-off.

Let me give you a real example.

Say you’re looking at an in-the-money (ITM) trade with about 1% cushion on a two-day option.

You might pay around $0.85 for that setup, giving you roughly a 20% ROI.

But if you extend that same trade out to next month, you might only pay $0.75 — and suddenly your ROI jumps to around 35%.

You’re trading time and volatility for better ROI — and in low-VIX environments, that can make all the difference.

Here’s the challenge though — especially with short-term trading.

A lot of this becomes systematic.

You have to decide: Do I want maximum ROI on a tight timeline, or do I want more breathing room and better odds of success?

And the difference can be dramatic.

Back in April 2025, when volatility was higher, our average cushion on similar trades sat around $3 below the close. That gave us plenty of room to work with.

But recently, we’ve had trades with just $0.58 of cushion on the same asset and time frame. That’s how much the environment can shift under your feet.

By adding just a little bit of time — going from 0DTE to 1DTE to 2DTE — you expand the market maker’s expected move, which means you’re giving yourself more ways to win.

It’s not a magic fix, but it’s a smart adjustment when the market isn’t giving you much volatility to work with.

Nate Tucci
Tucci Trades

Follow along and join the conversation for real-time analysis, trade ideas, market insights and more!

Important Note: No one from the New Money Crew team or Tucci Trades will ever contact you directly on Telegram.

*This is for informational and educational purposes only. There is inherent risk in trading, so trade at your own risk.

PS. Still haven’t tried the Income Machine yet?

Now’s your chance to do so… completely FREE 

You probably already know this…

But traders who have been using the Income Machine over the past few months have been going after the market daily…

Without the hassle of overthinking what setup to trade…

Without stressing about portfolio size…

And without being overwhelmed about how long to hold a position before they exit!

If you haven’t already, there’s no cause for alarm.

You can still get FREE access to the Income Machine, as well as 3 juicy income trades available to you right now.

The only thing I need to do is show you exactly how to use this one-of-a-kind engine… and you’re well on your way to a comfortable trading experience.

Get Your Free Access Here!

What to read next