🚨 I’ll be live at 9 a.m. ET🚨
Index efficiency is still alive and well despite bond yield woes. TLT caught a bid today: bottom or sell the rally? We also have non-farm payrolls on deck and more [tap to join us for the Daily Profit Plan]!
I’ve been digging into something that’s been bothering me, and I need to share what I’m seeing with dividend stocks…
Because what looks like safety on the surface might be setting you up for serious pain.
A lot of folks are getting drawn to high-yield stocks, thinking they’re finding value in beaten-down names. But when you’re collecting a 6% dividend while the stock drops 40% or more, that income isn’t doing you any favors.
This isn’t happening in isolation, either…
Roughly 80% of stocks in the S&P 500 are below their 50-day moving averages. That’s horrendous market breadth, and it tells us the weakness extends far beyond a handful of companies. When participation is this poor, even traditionally defensive stocks can remain under pressure.
The Math That Doesn’t Add Up
Take Clorox (CLX), which is yielding 6.17% but is down 67% from its highs. On paper, that yield looks attractive. In reality, you may be buying a falling knife.
Or consider PepsiCo (PEP), with a 4.67% dividend yield but down 36% from its peaks. Compare that with Coca-Cola (KO), which offers a 2.46% dividend and is trading just off all-time highs.
They’re in the same sector and both pay dividends — but their price action is completely different. One offers capital appreciation while the other loses value as it hands you a dividend check.
AT&T (T) yields 4.55%, but buying at $24 and watching it fall to $13 means a 43% loss. A 4.5% annual dividend doesn’t compensate for that drawdown. These examples show how badly consumer staples and other supposedly defensive names can get hit when investors focus on yield instead of total return.
The Pressure Beneath the Yield
Debt, higher borrowing and refinancing costs are the plague hitting these companies. When debt matures, a business may have to replace cheap financing with much more expensive capital.
That raises interest expense, squeezes margins and leaves less cash for operations, growth and dividends.
If cash flow deteriorates enough, management may need to slow dividend growth or cut the payout altogether. That can trigger another wave of selling, creating the classic dividend trap: The yield rises because the share price is collapsing, not because the investment is becoming safer.
That’s why I compare these stocks with alternatives. The iShares 0-3 Month Treasury Bond ETF (SGOV) offers exposure to short-term Treasurys with less price volatility and lower company-specific risk. Its yield can decline when interest rates fall, but you aren’t depending on one company’s balance sheet or dividend policy.
A box spread may offer another way to lock in a defined return, though it involves options, execution risk, tax considerations and assignment mechanics. It isn’t appropriate for everyone, but it highlights the opportunity cost of accepting equity downside for a similar income stream.
Look, I get the appeal of dividend investing. But when consumer staples have tumbled this hard and market breadth is this weak, you need to ask whether the yield is worth catching a falling knife.
Value isn’t value if the stock keeps dropping.
I’ll see you in the markets.
Chris Pulver
Chris Pulver TradingÂ
Follow along and join the conversation for real-time analysis, trade ideas, market insights and more!
- Telegram:https://t.me/+av20QmeKC5VjOTc5
- YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@FinancialWars
- Twitter:https://x.com/realchrispulver
- Facebook: https://facebook.com/therealchrispulver
Important Note: No one from the ProsperityPub team or Chris Pulver Trading will ever contact you directly on Telegram.
*This is for informational and educational purposes only. There is inherent risk in trading, so trade at your own risk.Â
P.S. The Modern Stock Market’s Morning Liquidity SurgeÂ
Most traders think capturing market moves requires staring at six screens all day…
But modern markets have changed the rules.
Massive daily options volume creates short-term liquidity surges that do the heavy lifting for you. And Nate just joined me to reveal the exact 9:35 a.m. ET setup step by step.
